Without Civics Education, Some Teens Say They’re Unprepared To Vote

by Noel Anaya
Also Featured on NPR's Morning Edition
10.28.16

On a recent fall morning at Lowell High School, a public school in San Francisco, Peer Resources teacher Adee Horn gathered her class together for a discussion about civics. “You have two questions,” she said, “One, do you feel prepared to vote? And two, what would it take for you to feel prepared to vote?”

Nineteen-year-old senior Hong Guan is one of the only kids in the class who raised his hand to say he actually feels ready to vote.

“Adults make us don’t feel like we’re ready,” he said. But we all should deserve a chance to vote. I had a really good social studies teacher. Like, when I came out of that class I felt ready to vote, and that was eighth grade.”

His classmate Lily Liang, 17, raised her hand to respond.

“Okay so that I think that Hong, you made really good points,” she said.  “But like what you’re saying is you feel ready and prepared to vote because you did your research and because of that great teacher that you had that made you feel ready. So many teenagers, they don’t have teachers that make like adults and make them feel ready to vote.”

Liang isn’t alone. I talked to several teens who are following the latest controversies in this election or, like me, are getting ready to vote for the first time. And many say they want more education about the election process.

More Civics Education Needed, Even in Swing States

Kei Kawashima-Ginsberg directs CIRCLE, a research center at Tufts University aimed at studying and boosting youth voter turnout. She says voter education in schools makes a big difference. “Simple things like bringing in the voting machine and let the students practice it,” can help students feel more prepared to vote, she says.

According to a 2013 survey from CIRCLE, teens who learned about voting in high school were about 40 percent more likely to cast ballots in the last presidential election. Civics classes also used to be where students debated issues and policies, but says Kawashima-Ginsberg, that’s totally changed.

“State standards in social studies really discourage teachers from really letting students explore what their belief systems are and how they relate to political ideology, and how that’s reflected in candidate’s policies and policy platforms,” she said.

At El Centro de Estudiantes, an alternative public high school in Philadelphia, 17-year-old Joselyn Figueroa-Rodriguez says her teachers generally avoid talking to students about politics “because they feel like that’s going to influence the way we vote.” She wishes her school taught more about the political system and how to take part in it, and says she plans to make the most of her swing-state vote as soon as she turns 18.

“I mean I think I should have a say in who’s leading the country that I’m living in,” she said. “Especially because I know what I need, and not only what I need but what we all need. Government help. School funding.”

San Francisco Considers Lowering Voting Age To Engage The Next Generation

Back in San Francisco, Lily Liang, the teen from earlier who isn’t sure she feels ready to vote, reflected on a revelation she had earlier this year when she volunteered to help at the polls during the California primary.

“It was actually really interesting,” Liang said. “From like a teenager standpoint I always thought adults knew what they were doing and they knew what ballots they wanted. But half the adults who I helped when I was working the polls, they like didn’t know what they were doing.”

Come November, San Francisco voters will decide on a ballot measure about whether to lower the voting age to 16 on local and school board elections. Based on what I’ve heard from young people, it’s a responsibility they would take seriously.

Support young journalists and artists