DISCUSSION: Can Gaming Teach You To Be a Better Citizen?
( Campers at the Summer of Minecraft Camp in Richmond, CA. Photo by: Olivia Cueva/Youth Radio)
Featured Media Resource: AUDIO: “Learning Coding and Citizenship” (NPR/Youth Radio)
This past summer, more than 2,000 kids around the country participated in the Summer of Minecraft Camp — a “virtual” summer camp where pre-teens log in from home in their pajamas and complete challenges with the help of online teenage counselors. While video games usually get a negative rap for teaching kids bad habits and manners, organizers say that games like Minecraft can actually teach important online social skills.
Do Now
What skills or lessons have you learned from playing online and video games? Do you think gaming can teach you how to be a better person? #DoNowGaming
How to Do Now
To respond to the Do Now, you can comment below or post your response on social media platforms such as Twitter, Instagram, Tumblr, Vine, Flickr, Google +, etc. Just be sure to include @KQEDedspace, @YouthRadio, and #DONOWGAMING in your posts.
Go here for best practices for using Do Now, using Twitter for teaching, and using otherdigital tools.
Learn More about the Debate Over Gaming
Video games are powerful tools — not just for having fun, but for interacting with other people. Whether those interactions end up teaching positive or negative lessons is a topic of hot debate in the education world.
Last year, the “Gamergate” controversycalled attention to a culture of sexism in some gaming circles, after prominent female game developers and professionals came forward with how they were harassed online. Critics have also pointed to the negative social messages associated with games like the Grand Theft Auto series, where players beat up or exploit other characters in order to advance. The evidence that violent video games can promote aggression in children, however, is still hotly debated.
In the midst of all the controversy about the psychological impacts of gaming, there is an emerging genre of so-called “empathy” games. In these games, players navigate a digital world from a vulnerable character’s perspective — say, a depression sufferer or a the parent of a child with cancer. And other popular online multiplayer games, like Minecraft, are being hailed as ways to teach kids both technical skills and socialization — so much that video game “summer camps” are popping up to facilitate students game-learning.
This summer, Youth Radio’s Kasey Saeturn went to one such camp, called the Summer of Minecraft, where pre-teen gamers were being tutored by teenage counselors on their digital citizenship. Seventeen-year-old Ryan Dempsey said a big part of his job as a counselor is to teach kids how to keep it positive online.
“They get mad that they lost, and they will call people names,” he said. “A lot of it is just like, ‘You’re mean,’ or stupid or idiots.”
With the proper direction, he also sees kids come together in the game, protecting each other while they heal or giving each other encouragement. Learning online social skills is vital, says Caroline Knorr, an editor for Common Sense Media, an organization that helps parents make informed choices about kids’ media and technology. “Understanding that there are actual people on the other side of the screen is really one of the most essential skills that kids can learn,” she says. “That’s what leads to empathy.”
Do Next
Do Next takes the online conversation to the next level: these are suggestions for ways to go out into your community and investigate how the topic featured in this Do Now impacts people’s lives. Use digital storytelling tools and social media to share your story and take action. Make sure to tag your creations with #DONOWGAMING.
- Gaming Ground Rules: Come up with a training video or skit addressing the question of how not to be a troll or a cyberbully online. You can tailor the training to your favorite game or social media outlet, and come up with examples of “do’s” and “don’ts” for being a good online citizen. You can edit your video with the free online editing tool We Video.
- Gaming Review: Have a discussion with your friends and classmates about the life lessons you learned from specific games you play. Consider the actions of characters in the game, the actions you can take as part of the game, and the challenges/decisions you face in order to “win.” Come up with rankings of your top games, and post your list online.
- Ask a Game Designer: Come up with interview questions for the designer of your favorite video game. Reach out to them via the company websites or social media to see if they are willing to answer your questions! For help coming up with questions, check out Youth Radio’s Interviewing Toolkit, which includes tips for Interviewing Experts.Share a photo or link to a blog post with your questions and the responses from the company.
More Resources
ARTICLE: Why Video Games Can’t Teach You Empathy (Motherboard)
Empathy games are supposed to teach you how to be a more compassionate person, but do they really work? This article gives a broad overview of some popular types of empathy games and the controversies associated with the genre. For example, Anna Anthropy, creator of Dys4ia, a game where you play a transgender woman and that she says she designed for the trans community, says her game has been misappropriated as an empathy-builder. “If you’ve played a 10-minute game about being a transwoman, don’t pat yourself on the back for feeling like you understand a marginalized experience,” she said.
CURRICULUM (for teachers): Teaching Digital Citizenship K-12 (Common Sense Media)
Common Source Media’s teaching materials are designed “to empower students to think critically, behave safely, and participate responsibly in our digital world.”
VIDEO: Using Minecraft as an Educational Tool (Edutopia) Are you out of the Minecraft loop? Get to know the basics in this video, which shows how some educators are using the game to teach middle school students communication, collaboration and digital citizenship.